| Moderated by: chrisbet, |
|
|
| Nikon 1 v1 vs Fuji x100 | Rating: 
|
| Author | Post |
|---|
| Posted by Squarerigger: Fri May 4th, 2012 15:47 | 1st Post |
| I know several of you own the Fuji x100 and seem to really like the camera. My question is if you did not already own the Fuji x100, would you be tempted to purchase the Nikon1 v1 instead?
____________________ -------------------------------------------- Gary |
| Posted by richw: Sat May 5th, 2012 01:22 | 2nd Post |
| A friend asked me this recently. I replied that I would buy the Fuji for myself, but the Nikon for my wife. The Fuji is capable of a better IQ (particularly in lower light), but is a bitch to use, the Nikon might not have the same IQ but is easier to use and focuses quickly.
|
| Posted by jk: Sat May 5th, 2012 05:23 | 3rd Post |
| I keep thinking that the Nikon V1 would be a nice walk around camera but the X100 that I have provides that function as it is so small but has only a 23mm (35mm on FX) lens. In my view this is the only 'failing' of the X100. Of course now I have the XPro1 I am spoilt completely as its 16MP sensor is so good and so sharp it is the equal of my D3 apart from speed of focus. The AF on the V1 is superior as it is very quick but the smaller sensor is for me a problem. The V2 when it comes later this year or next year will be right up there as I expect that Nikon will have move the sensor technology forward so a CX sensor will have as good IQ as a 10MP DX of 2011. The huge advantage of the V1 is that it can use Nikon AFS lenses but also the 10-30 zoom that is its kit lens is also very good.
____________________ Still learning after all these years! https://nikondslr.uk/gallery_view.php?user=2&folderid=none |
| Posted by TomOC: Sun May 6th, 2012 15:07 | 4th Post |
| I think it will be quite a while before there is a camera to beat the x100 - for what I like about it... Let me explain. As JK says the xpro1 beats it in some ways, the N1 beats it in features, obviously the D3 beats it in some ways. If you want a camera that will literally fit easily in your jacket pocket (or cargo pants) then the one with the best IQ is the x100. You have to zoom with your feet - think of it as a 35mm lens in your pocket. For me the only other choice would be the Leica X1 but this lacks a viewfinder and that got old very quickly. The hybrid viewfinder in the x100/xpro-1 is the most amazing new development ever!! You switch from EVF to Leica style VF with a switch ! You just have to get used to it to believe it. I have been a nut for every new P&S dream camera every year, and every year, I quickly sold each CAnon G series on ebay before the price went down. I tried olympus, leica, and nikon ones...all fell short due to the small sensor (probably the best in the group was canon). I know the N1 has some pretty good reviews, but it is still in the small sensor camp and will eventually disappoint in my opinion. If you know you will never want a print larger than 8x10 and never will need a serious crop done, then go for it, as you probably won't be able tell much difference, but if you want really low light capability, large stunning prints that you are used to with your Nikon dslr, go with the largest sensor you can get... Cheers, Tom
____________________ Tom O'Connell -Lots of people talk to animals.... Not very many listen, though.... That's the problem. Benjamin Hoff, The Tao of Pooh |
| Posted by Eric: Sun May 6th, 2012 15:19 | 5th Post |
TomOC wrote:I think it will be quite a while before there is a camera to beat the x100 - for what I like about it... That sums it up very well Tom. I decided NOT to go for the xpro1 because I felt it was turning into a bigger and bigger lump in the pocket. I have found the combination of the X100 in my pocket and the D7000 with a 55-200 in my hand are an ideal walkaround, holiday combo. Although a D800 may displace the D7000 in due course 
____________________ Eric |
| Posted by Squarerigger: Sun May 6th, 2012 17:03 | 6th Post |
| I am trying to remember, but I think most who own the X100 have responded. I thank you for your opinions on the two cameras. I do not have a small carry about which could be used as a backup should my D7000 got belly up at some very inconvenient time. There are plenty of times when I am just out an about and wish I had a good quality camera with me. After reading all the reviews on the internet, well not all of them, and reading your comments, I find myself drawn to the x100 over the Nikon 1 V1. I think the over riding factor for me is the inability to change lenses on the x100. The Nikon 1 v1 would temp one to get the adapter and use all the lenses one already owns which would defeat the pocket camera attempt or backup emergency camera. I read reviews of folks taking the Nikon 1 v1 and they are already turning it into another body to attach to their 70-200mm etc. I like the idea of a fixed lens and the return to my days when I had my FM and no zoom lenses. Don't get me wrong, I love my zoom lenses but for a pocket and backup camera I don't want another complete system. Again thanks for the guidance and help and time.
____________________ -------------------------------------------- Gary |
| Posted by richw: Sun May 6th, 2012 17:28 | 7th Post |
| Just be aware that it's not as easy to use as a DSLR.
|
| Posted by jk: Sun May 6th, 2012 17:46 | 8th Post |
richw wrote:Just be aware that it's not as easy to use as a DSLR. That is definitely the case. It is not a small DSLR.
____________________ Still learning after all these years! https://nikondslr.uk/gallery_view.php?user=2&folderid=none |
| Posted by Eric: Mon May 7th, 2012 05:21 | 9th Post |
jk wrote: richw wrote:In use its like a film camera was 60+ years ago ...but with shot review and a heap of other digital aids ...IF YOU WANT TO USE THEM. To anyone considering buying an X100 I would recommend they first put a 35mm lens on their DSLR (or tape their zoom down to 35mm) and go out shooting with it like that for a day. To me THAT is the biggest challenge to your photography...being fixed to a wide angle lens. Dont get me wrong, it can be a cathartic experience and help your creativity. (I used to take just a 50mm out for the day perioodically to refresh my eye.) But it can be a culture shock and a frustration when you have a distant shot you cant reach. The composite image below is of two shots taken in Bruges last year. My wife drew my attention to a bay window over a shop with 'someone' in it as we ambled around the town. I instinctively used the X100 hanging around my neck to take a shot (left)...then grabbed the D7000 with 200mm available (right). So not having extra reach available can sometimes be an issue. Attachment: _DSC4192.jpg (Downloaded 49 times)
____________________ Eric |
| Posted by jk: Mon May 7th, 2012 14:31 | 10th Post |
Eric said: I'd definitely agree with that and it is the one reason why I purchased the Xpro1. I couldnt manage without a short telephoto. I love the 70-90mm range on a camera. I couldnt achieve this with the X100 no matter how I tried. The closest I got was a x2 converter that vignetted slightly. This was a real pain.
____________________ Still learning after all these years! https://nikondslr.uk/gallery_view.php?user=2&folderid=none |
| Posted by richw: Tue May 8th, 2012 04:45 | 11th Post |
Eric said: You mean 'after remembering to take the lens cap off'? (only wish I was joking).
|
| Posted by jk: Tue May 8th, 2012 06:38 | 12th Post |
richw wrote: Eric said: Rich you dont have to use the lens cap if you make up one of these. The Fuji filter attachment/ hood ring or other clone from HK and a 49-28mm reducer. I have a 49mm filter in between the ring and the reduce to provide dust protection also. All bits cost me about £5. Attachment: D300-1-7023.jpg (Downloaded 36 times)
____________________ Still learning after all these years! https://nikondslr.uk/gallery_view.php?user=2&folderid=none |
| Posted by Squarerigger: Tue May 8th, 2012 07:38 | 13th Post |
Eric wrote:jk wrote:richw wrote:In use its like a film camera was 60+ years ago ...but with shot review and a heap of other digital aids ...IF YOU WANT TO USE THEM. Wow Eric, is that a real person in the window? Seriously, she looks like a wax figure, was going to say dummy, in the window. I have to say, I think I would be very uncomfortable taking a photo of someone in their own home on the sly. Were you paparazzi in a former life?  
____________________ -------------------------------------------- Gary |
| Posted by Graham Whistler: Mon May 21st, 2012 06:43 | 14th Post |
| The V1 Nikon is very good too. My wife Wendy took this last week at Chatsworth house in Derbyshire. Available light hand held 1/60sec f3.5 1600ISO 10mm with the 10-30mm lens. It was a JPG file but detail is good and highlights held and colour not bad for auto setting. Perhaps we should have posted some of Wendy's shots in our USA trip she like me was very happy with her results. Attachment: Wen1157.jpg (Downloaded 26 times)
____________________ Graham Whistler |
| Posted by Graham Whistler: Mon May 21st, 2012 06:47 | 15th Post |
| This is also at Chatsworth and is part of picture only to show detail. 10-30mm lens in bright conditions, some loss of highlight detail on back of head, perhaps would have retained more with NEF rather that JPG? Attachment: Wen1170.jpg (Downloaded 26 times)
____________________ Graham Whistler |
| Posted by Squarerigger: Mon May 21st, 2012 08:05 | 16th Post |
| Thanks for the information Graham. The photos from the V1 look very good. May I ask if you purchased any other lenses beside the 10-30mm and how they fair?
____________________ -------------------------------------------- Gary |
| Posted by Graham Whistler: Mon May 21st, 2012 08:31 | 17th Post |
| Yes Wendy also has the 30-110 lens and results from that are also very sharp.
____________________ Graham Whistler |
| Posted by Squarerigger: Mon May 21st, 2012 08:37 | 18th Post |
| I see Nikon has the V1 bundled with the 10-30mm and the 30-110mm. That would make for a very attractive kit. Always good to get the perspective of a user of the equipment.
____________________ -------------------------------------------- Gary |
| Posted by jk: Mon May 21st, 2012 13:36 | 19th Post |
richw wrote: Rich,Eric said: Try these tricks. I noticed a simple trick this evening that checks in OVF whether you have the lens cap on or not. 1. If you look at the Histogram box in bottom left this is empty if the lens cap is on as there is no light impacting on the sensor!.. Simple. 2. This wont work for those who MF. If you press the shutter release to focus you get the Red box of failure. No AF!! No light so image, no AF. So simple  Hope these help reduce the black shot syndrome.
____________________ Still learning after all these years! https://nikondslr.uk/gallery_view.php?user=2&folderid=none |
| Posted by jk: Mon May 21st, 2012 13:38 | 20th Post |
| Ed Constable did some ISO tests for me with his V1. We concluded that ISO800 was about the cut off limit. In bright conditions you would need to look hard at the images to discern which camera took which image if you were comparing with a DX camera. Image quality is considerably better than a point'n'shoot compact.
____________________ Still learning after all these years! https://nikondslr.uk/gallery_view.php?user=2&folderid=none |
| Posted by TomOC: Mon May 21st, 2012 14:30 | 21st Post |
Eric wrote:
Eric- I agree. I keep the x100 in my car and it is the one I use most, but if I know I'm going out for a "photo walk" I'll take the xp1 - almost always with the 35mm (50mm equivalent) and it is really taking you back to the 60s and I love it. The xp1 and a lens or two is still less expensive than the 24-70 nikkor and more fun (but not as versatile . Funny how you go through phases where most shots are tele shots and then back to more "normal" ranges... I'm in the "normal" phase right now (at least as normal as I can be Basically, the x100 is the most fun you can put in your pocket after the iphone... Cheers, Tom
____________________ Tom O'Connell -Lots of people talk to animals.... Not very many listen, though.... That's the problem. Benjamin Hoff, The Tao of Pooh |
| Posted by jk: Mon May 21st, 2012 15:12 | 22nd Post |
| Yes, I certainly agree with that but I do love the XP1 with 60mm. Must be in my tele phase!
____________________ Still learning after all these years! https://nikondslr.uk/gallery_view.php?user=2&folderid=none |
| Posted by TomOC: Mon May 21st, 2012 15:14 | 23rd Post |
| If this keeps up, I might even lose a little weight. I seem to be taking more aimless walks lately Tom
____________________ Tom O'Connell -Lots of people talk to animals.... Not very many listen, though.... That's the problem. Benjamin Hoff, The Tao of Pooh |
| This is topic ID = 133 | ||
| Nikon DSLR Forums > Camera and Lens Forums > Cameras > Nikon 1 v1 vs Fuji x100 | Top | |
Users viewing this topic |
||
Current theme is Blue
| A small amount of member data is captured and held in an attempt to reduce spammers and to manage users. This site also uses cookies to ensure ease of use. In order to comply with new DPR regulations you are required to agree/disagree with this process. If you do not agree then please email the Admins using info@nikondsl.uk Thank you. |
Hosted by Octarine Services
UltraBB 1.173 Copyright © 2008-2024 Data 1 Systems
Page processed in 0.1760 seconds (85% database + 15% PHP). 156 queries executed.
UltraBB 1.173 Copyright © 2008-2024 Data 1 Systems
Page processed in 0.1760 seconds (85% database + 15% PHP). 156 queries executed.